Search:

SIYE Time:14:01 on 20th April 2024
SIYE Login: no


Reviewer: skiutahnum1 Signed Date: 2020.04.12 - 03:45PM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarhalf-star

Well I’m glad to see how this ride ended but I’m also glad to see some progress...kutgw



Reviewer: FavChanger Signed Date: 2019.08.25 - 06:04AM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

I love this story. I really do.

Your interpretations of the characters are just amazing. Harry and Ginny's innocent love for each other, the banter between them, I just love them. Ron, Hermione, Neville, Hagrid, Fred & George, they all feel like they've been ripped straight from canon. Ron's still immature, lazy and a prat at times, but you can still feel that loyalty from him, the hidden genius of his mind and the love he has for his friends. Hermione perfectly lives up to her moniker of "brilliant, but scary." Fred & George are hilarious and loyal.

Then you add whole new layers to other characters like Dumbledore, McGonagall, Percy, Molly, and Arthur. The conflicts with Dumbledore and Molly make sense, but do nothing to reduce the love I have for the original interpretation. In other fics like Backwards with Purpose, I just stopped reading after the Weasley family became hostile. You properly hint at the future conflicts the Weasley family could have with Percy.

And then there's Arthur and McGonagall. By god, I love them so much. The parental roles they've both filled for Harry and Ginny have actually made me cry at points. You make me wich that McGonagall had a bigger role in the originals. I already loved McGonagall before reading this, but seriously, I just can't get enough of her. And then Arthur, I can seriously compare him to Atticus Finch from To Kill A Mockingbird. You take this quirky, and somewhat bumbling character from the original and turn him into an experienced father of seven/eight. I'm legitimately scared that they might both die, thanks to J.K's habit of killing of Harry's parental figures. The best part about all of this is that you add new conflicts between characters, yet you treat them all with respect, and not with the tropey bashing I always loathe.

Your handling of common tropes that are still used today is unique and interesting. The Soul-Bond has it's share of pros and cons, yet you are able to masterfully convey just how much Harry and Ginny love and need it, I feel jealous of the two of them. I also love that (at least so far) that the bond doesn't have "stages" you typically see in othe fics. Powerful!Harry is shown as both a dangerous curse yet full of potential just waiting to be used. You introduce all of the rules of the bond and you stick to them, which allows Harry and Ginny to develop their relationship in an organic way as opposed to being forced or "nudged" by the bond itself. I also love your explanation of the bond's existance that was built in the prologue, which was basically fate or whatever going "$#!+, Voldemort and Harry exist and their about to ram into each other! How do we fix this? Uh... Ginny!" And the fact that it is the first known example of a bond in your story, as opposed to Flamel-Ex-Machina or something similar being an exposition dump. It conveys the soul of what magic is, something fantastical that cannot be explained, that you can see in J.K's portrayal of the power of love.

I get seriously emotional when I read this. You're able to make me laugh, cry, tense up, forget to breathe, and make unbearably happy, much more than the original books ever did for me. I was legitimately scared during the third-floor corridor. Ginny's triumphant entry into the Quidditch Pitch left me with an absolutely stupid grin on my face. McGonagall comforting Ginny after the nightmares in the Hospital wing was heartbreaking. I feel just as dissapointed in Molly as Arthur is after that Christmas debacle. I could go on and on.

Either way, I can't wait to see more from you. Meaning of One or otherwise.



Reviewer: Hufflepuffiest Signed Date: 2018.03.23 - 11:14PM Title: Reason

Great story, one of the the best bonding stories I’ve read.



Reviewer: Gin110881 Signed Date: 2016.08.18 - 07:16AM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

I wanted to read this story for ages. But because the second part seemed to be abandoned, I kept it back for a special occasion, e.g. when I need a safe haven to lighten my mood after accidentally running into an angsty story with lots of constructed relationship rubbish.
But the most recent update of part two of the story was reason enough to read the story immediately. And I'm glad that I've done it. I must confess that I wasn't surprised that the all the praises for the story are well justified. I loved the story and I'm really glad that I can read part two right away. Of course, the icing on the top is that part two is even completed now.
A big THANK YOU for this wonderful story.



Reviewer: Ranma-sensei Signed Date: 2014.06.15 - 07:31AM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

I have got to say that this is the most well thought-out version of the soul-bond fanfiction I have ever read. While it does seem strange how Harry and Ginny react to it, what with them being pre-teens, it is relatively well-explained with the prologue and Ginny's precocious nature. And they DO feel awkward at first; they only realize that it will not matter in the end, as they could always accidentally watch the memories afterwards (THANKS, Mister Weasley!).

I also like how the both of them discern that they love each other - it makes it all the more sweeter that they acknowledge it at the year's end.

What I am really curious about is that Ron seems to guess that he killed the troll. Either that or he is horrified to see what happens when he looses his temper.

Also sorry about the thing with the pyjamas; I didn't realize you had corrected it in the later chapters. And the thing about Pinky and the Brain starting in 1995 was meant to say that I didn't see Harry and Ginny's lines as deliberate paraphrasing, but a joke on your part.

All in all, I look forward to start reading about their second year. After breakfast, of course. :)

Keep narrating,
Ranma-sensei



Reviewer: I Love Ginerva Signed Date: 2013.06.06 - 07:02AM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarhalf-star

I almost forgot to leave a Review... I enjoyed the story. I've read the first chapter of part two.

Rating is for the entire story

ILG



Reviewer: YeCatsJ Signed Date: 2011.10.14 - 07:36AM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

Awesome story!! I actually had to pause before reading the part about the jumpers. I honestly didn't know if Molly would give Harry a jumper or not and then read about the book and the fight - it was brillant writing!!!!

Looking forward to part 2. I hope you may see time to write more sometime. Great Job!!!



Reviewer: RWHGHP51892 Signed Date: 2011.07.24 - 04:17PM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

No Review



Reviewer: sonotawriter Signed Date: 2011.01.25 - 02:21PM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

I'm a late arrival on the fan fiction scene, so I'm fortunate that I get to read a lot of completed stories. I enjoyed this one very much. I was impressed by several things, not least the humour you included in your story, and your descriptions were so real I could create very vivid mental images of my own based on your words. Wonderful stuff and I look forward to reading the rest of your work

Elizabeth



Reviewer: hptrump Signed Date: 2010.08.15 - 12:22AM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

Love your story. Hope you write all seven years.

Author's Response: Thank you. I hope to.



Reviewer: lemsv Signed Date: 2010.07.13 - 08:40PM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

I guess it is the very first 10 I give for a story but il think it IS well deserved! It was very nice and fun to read. I even lost some sleep in the process and my girlfriend is not that happy about that.
Many thanks for your story. It is 2:35 AM and I look foward to read the second part! I do hope you will continue your story! Thanks again for your work.

Author's Response: Thanks very much for the kind words. I hope you managed some sleep before beginning part two.



Reviewer: Rycr Signed Date: 2010.07.08 - 03:47AM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant. A wonderful ending to a wonderful series. I especially loved Arthur's threats to the Dursleys (and how he implied that Petunia knows more than is apparent, as we found out in later books) and that final scene with Harry returning to the Burrow made me go "awww" at its cuteness. Well done, sir. I look forward to reading your sequel in a moment.

Author's Response: Thanks very much. There's probably more cuteness in this story than there will be in any others, but I suppose that's appropriate given their ages.



Reviewer: Wildfire142 Signed Date: 2010.03.06 - 06:46AM Title: Reason

Great writing, just spent every free moment over the last three days reading all of this :)

Author's Response: Thanks, I'm glad you enjoyed it. Get some sleep!



Reviewer: Wildfire142 Signed Date: 2010.03.06 - 06:41AM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

No Review



Reviewer: BennettPotter Signed Date: 2010.02.03 - 10:02PM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

All I can say is wow! I just discovered SIYE a few weeks ago (this is actually my first review) and have had fun with the random story link and I discovered your story Ages. It was so wonderful and touching that I immediately started reading this story. I've read a lot of great and a lot of bad fanfiction, but I have to say that this is one of the best stories I've ever read. I laughed, I cried, I stayed up past 3 am several times to finish reading a few more chapters!

First, I really loved how this was about friendship. I really enjoy the "bonding" genre in HP fanfic, but it often bothers me that most of these stories have an underlying adult theme to them. To me, the bonding theme is one about finding your soul mate. That being said, it should first of all be about friendship, understanding, respect, and a deep connection (IMHO, the building blocks to a successful relationship). They are only 10 and 11 and shouldn't have a certain type of physical relationship (although I laught at the thought of what it will be like for Harry many, many years from now when he and Ginny are married and she experiences childbirth - considering that they feel each others pain). So, thank you for this. It made the story so much more believable and set such a great tone for their relationship. I look forward to seeing how their love changes from the end of part 1 through the end of the series.

Second, the depth of the characters is amazing. It broke my heart to think of the abuse that Harry suffered at Privet Drive (something often overlooked because JKR was writing a "childrens" book). Molly's behavior towards Harry also broke my heart. I'm so used to seeing her as a surrogate mother to Harry that it was hard to read some parts of this story. Although, if I had a 10 year-old daughter, I'd probably be just as scared and over-protective as Molly. I'm looking forward to your development of the Harry/Molly relationship (I hope she eventually becomes a mum to him). I loved how Arthur was such a critical part of the family relationship and the voice of reason for the family with regards to Harry's and Ginny's relationship. I love how Charlie apologized by doing (my dad and my boyfriend both do that - it drives me crazy but I love them for it anyway). I loved learning more about the personalities of Charlie and Big Bill. I always felt that we never learned enough about them in the books.

I have to admit that I'm stressed about pompous Percy knowing about Harry and Ginny; I'm afraid that he tell Fudge or Umbridge about it and that's a bad thing. The red-headed bookends were great. That' s how I always pictured the twins. I love their interaction with "Hinny/Garry". Even in the books, they were always so accepting of Harry in their family's life. I hope a certain event that happens to a twin in book 7 does not happen in your story. I feel like your Griffindors have a much stonger bond/friendship much earlier in the series than the original. I look forward to seeing how that affects them moving forward. Love Minerva...I always knew she had a heart of gold beneath that hard exterior. Who would have thought that she would end up being Harry and Ginny's biggest advocates?

Sorry it is such a long review, but I loved this story so much and could tell that you put a lot of heart into it. I felt the least I could do is express my thanks and excitement. You have the hard job of writing and I get the fun job of reading. I can't decide if I want to re-read this one after I hit the submit button or if I should start reading part 2 (or one of your other stories). Keep up the outstanding work!

Author's Response: Firstly, welcome to SIYE! Though by now I'm quite late in replying to your review. I hope you've enjoyed the site in the meantime.
I completely agree with you about the bonding. For the whole thing to work, it has to start with friendship, even for older people. Given that H/G here are only 11/10, it's even more obvious to me that their relationship should look like a deep friendship at this point. It's going somewhere, of course, but it doesn't have to get there immediately. (You're right, though, about what Harry has to look forward to.)
The Weasleys are such great characters in canon, but at the same time they're sadly underutilized. Molly can't be just the perfect mother-figure. Arthur can't just be a Muggle-obsessed father of 7. They all have dimension, and I really wanted to fill in some of the gaps. Arthur, in particular, gets his chance to shine in this story, because I think it's the sort of situation that would bring him to the forefront of the family dynamic (as wasn't really necessary in canon).
I've pondered that earlier bond amongst the kids that you mentioned. I think that even in canon, Ginny is more like the twins than like Ron, and the three of them clearly got along well. At the same time, Ginny and Ron were playmates for years while the rest were at school, so I think they were close in their way before Ron went to Hogwarts and made new friends. So when you put Ginny into the story at Hogwarts at the same time as Ron, their relationship doesn't have a chance to falter and fade out, and at the same time Ginny's put back with the twins. Given her personality, I think it's pretty natural for her to act as a unifying force between Ron and the twins. In MoO, adding Harry to that mix is a given. That leaves Hermione, really, as the only new character, and I think she and Ginny would be drawn together from the moment they took up residence in the dormitory. So, anyway, that's my thinking behind the whole group's dynamic. I'm glad you're liking it.
I love long reviews, and I'm prone to leaving long responses. Thanks very much for reading the story and taking the time to share your opinion in detail. A good, long review is the best part of writing fanfic.
Thanks!



Reviewer: RealmofShadows Signed Date: 2009.11.08 - 12:45PM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

Hi Sovran:

I wanted to let you know that this was a truly amazing story and a truly amazing journey!! I have really enjoyed your story and you definately deserved the DSTA'S!!!!

Great writing and I can't wait to see more!!

Please keep it up!!

Thanks again for a great story!

Author's Response: Thanks very much. I've had a great time writing this series, and I'm very glad that people enjoy reading it.



Reviewer: juice14 Signed Date: 2009.08.14 - 05:29AM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

That was certainly one of the best fanfics I've come across.... certainly deserves all the DSTAs heh

I think I need not say more regarding how good your writing is but was hoping if I could gain some insight....

I was wondering if you chose to deliberately join them at this early point in their age to duplicate the canon timeline? Or perhaps it would be easier to deal with the innocence of a child regarding such a bond of love/affection?

I sometimes come across issues reading about people's stories and comments regarding the implications of sexual desire with the younger versions of Harry and Ginny. Personally, I belong more to the 'Arthur Weasley' view of things. It is precisely that they are so young that they have not been corrupted by the world's view of sex and violence. That makes the bond between them somewhat more extraordinary. Not sure if this was one of the reasons you had behind starting your AU storyline so early.

This is quite a sticky topic but I think you got the intent behind their close relationship down pat. Perfect descriptions and scenes. I think one of the best ones is the bit where Bill and Harry agree... 'for Ginny'. Sometimes I envy these characters of fantasy and can only hope I can love my fiancee as much in real life.

Thank you for giving this story to the world. I'd like to believe that even JK Rowling would be proud that her creations have taken on even more life and love. I know I'm a fan hehe :)



Author's Response: That's a really good question. Three are basically two reasons I started the story when I did. First, if they had joined much sooner, the story would have gone in a completely different direction, which I don't think I or you would have enjoyed as much. Given that, I needed a catalyst for the unification to occur, and their first meeting seemed most reasonable and logical. Second, I saw a lot of opportunities for character and plot development if I started the unification on 9/1/1991 rather than later. I think later would have been easier in a lot of ways, but a lot of the story elements I wanted to tell depended on starting everything sooner. My version of the Chamber plot, which has really only just begun, would never have been possible without the union in place beforehand. And, yes, I do think that starting before puberty makes the effects of the union more profound. In the end, I think Ginny's parents would find it easier to accept the bond than they would have if it had begun a few years later.
I think I'd melt into a puddle if JKR read this story, but I do hope she'd like it. And I hope she wouldn't send lawyers. Lawyers are never a good sign.
Thanks for reading. On to Part Two.



Reviewer: Zanthus Signed Date: 2009.05.01 - 09:52PM Title: Reason

And also for giving Minerva more strength and involvement and showing Molly with all her power.
Cheers
Z

Author's Response: And thanks again.



Reviewer: Zanthus Signed Date: 2009.05.01 - 09:52PM Title: Reason

And also for giving Minerva more strength and involvement and showing Molly with all her power.
Cheers
Z

Author's Response: Thanks. I really like those two characterizations.



Reviewer: Zanthus Signed Date: 2009.05.01 - 09:48PM Title: Reason

starstarstarstarstar

G’day mate,
What a bloody ripper of a yarn. I can see why it won the DSTA. Loved your aspect of it. Ch 12 to 16 were diabolically good. How you went from extremely good humour to drama and back would have made Hitchcock proud. Your style definitely has me sucked in. Luckily there is more of you works to be read. Enjoy the future.
Z


Author's Response: Thanks very much. I hope you enjoy the other stories as well.




../back
‘! Go To Top ‘!

Sink Into Your Eyes is hosted by Grey Media Internet Services. HARRY POTTER, characters, names and related characters are trademarks of Warner Bros. TM & © 2001-2006. Harry Potter Publishing Rights © J.K.R. Note the opinions on this site are those made by the owners. All stories(fanfiction) are owned by the author and are subject to copyright law under transformative use. Authors on this site take no compensation for their works. This site © 2003-2006 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Special thanks to: Aredhel, Kaz, Michelle, and Jeco for all the hard work on SIYE 1.0 and to Marta for the wonderful artwork.
Featured Artwork © 2003-2006 by Yethro.
Design and code © 2006 by SteveD3(AdminQ)
Additional coding © 2008 by melkior and Bear