Reviews For The Circle
Reviewer: GinervaMollyWeasley Signed Date: 2006.08.23 - 10:05PM Title: Upset and Insight I loved it. Yes, Ron is good for some things.. and downright hot at other times, too. But Harry is hotter. Reviewer: Merlani Signed Date: 2006.02.26 - 12:17AM Title: Upset and Insight read for judging purpose. good luck! Reviewer: KikiDeeDee Anonymous Date: 2006.02.21 - 02:06PM Title: Upset and Insight Judged for the Challenge. Nice little entry. Sneaky to put the good bit right at the end. Good Luck Kiki Reviewer: jaquelyne and mom Anonymous Date: 2006.02.17 - 10:19AM Title: Upset and Insight red for contest. Reviewer: Spenser Hemmingway Signed Date: 2006.02.10 - 10:19PM Title: Upset and Insight Even prat brothers are useful huh? This 'circle' support group is an interesting idea. It could be useful for all manner of insightful dialogue. I would love to hear them again on Saturday after the trip to Hogsmeade. Thanks. Eric B. Reviewer: sugarquill112 Signed Date: 2006.02.06 - 07:27AM Title: Upset and Insight I enjoyed reading your fic. It is rather short but interesting. I really liked 'The Circle'; it's quite intriguing. It's good that you used the bonus phrases. I read and reviewed this for judging purposes. Best of luck for the contest.
Reviewer: Telwyn Dubois Signed Date: 2006.02.06 - 12:44AM Title: Upset and Insight Read for judging purposes.
I like the idea of a "circle", and Ginny being in charge of everything. There are a few grammar issues, but they are so miniscule, it's not worth pointing out. Gin's use of Hermione's famous last words was apt, though the going starkers part seemed a bit forced. At any rate, it was a nice read, so good luck in the challenge!
Telly Reviewer: Jim McGuffin Signed Date: 2006.01.25 - 01:15AM Title: Upset and Insight Nice little ficlet, albeit a little on the short side.
You state that this is a seventh-year fic, but without the horcruxes. That's OK -- I suppose the horcrux hunt wouldn't quite fit here. That's an interesting idea, there being a place where Ginny and her roommates regularly meet to discuss -- what else -- boys. At least Ginny has a good day coming up with Harry after all.
Overall, short and sweet. I wish you luck in the challenge. Reviewer: cori_b Anonymous Date: 2006.01.24 - 12:04AM Title: Upset and Insight Judging for Challenge. I found it very interesting and like I said in my previous review... I liked the idea. I also liked how Ginny quoted Hermione in the last few lines. Well done. I hope you do well! Reviewer: Beanie Signed Date: 2006.01.23 - 07:06PM Title: Upset and Insight Hehe, that was nifty. Turn out another chapter soon, 'kay? It made me giggle! And it had potential to be something truely brilliant. It just leaves a lot of room for a good plot, you know?
PS: Is everyone getting their stories reviewed by a common beta? 'Cause you're the second person I've seen who spells "of course" "of coarse".
PS Number Two: I give it a ten! =D Reviewer: cori_b Anonymous Date: 2006.01.22 - 10:14PM Title: Upset and Insight sweet, In the school where I live they have something like "a Circle" but its called osmething diffrent. Its primarily a place wehre teens get guidance from a teacher and teens. Reviewer: greybackfenrir Anonymous Date: 2006.01.22 - 09:48PM Title: Upset and Insight humorous fic that I quite enjoyed. : ) Reviewer: Ginebra Wood Signed Date: 2006.01.22 - 12:44PM Title: Upset and Insight Good one really, I found the Circlke very usefull. I qill judging your ficf. Good Luck Reviewer: The Real Nymphadora Signed Date: 2006.01.22 - 08:34AM Title: Upset and Insight oh that was very good (hehe) | |||||||
|